Freelance vs. Independent Contractor: What All Business Owners Should Know

As a business owner, making the decision to hire additional help can be a daunting task. When it comes to expanding your team, you can take your pick between a freelance or independent contractor vs. employee. 

It's important to understand the difference between the two, as each option has its own benefits and drawbacks. In this article, we'll dive into the world of independent contractors and freelancers and explore the key differences between the two. 

By the end, you'll have a clearer understanding of the pros and cons of each and be better equipped to make an informed decision for your business. 

Let's get started.

‍

What is a Freelancer?

Freelancers are self-employed individuals who work independently and offer their services to multiple clients on a project basis. They are not committed to any long-term contract with a particular client or receive any employee benefits. Freelancers typically have a specific skill set, such as writing, graphic design, web development, or consulting, which they use to provide their services.

Characteristics of a Freelancer

• Freedom and Flexibility: Freelancers can choose their clients, work hours, and location.
• Specialised Skills: Freelancers often have a specific area of expertise and can offer a high level of skill and knowledge in their field.
• Self-employment: Freelancers are responsible for managing their own business operations, including invoicing, taxes, and marketing.
• Project-based work: Freelancers typically work on a project-by-project basis and are not committed to any long-term contract with a particular client.

Benefits of Hiring a Freelancer

• Cost-effective: Freelancers are usually less expensive than hiring a full-time employee, as they do not require benefits or office space.
• Expertise: Freelancers have specialised skills and can provide high-quality work.
• Flexibility: Freelancers offer flexibility, as they can be hired for short-term or long-term projects and can adjust their work hours to meet tight deadlines.
• Low risk: Freelancers do not require a long-term commitment, which minimises the risk of hiring someone who may not be a good fit for the company.

Drawbacks of Hiring a Freelancer

• Lack of Control: Business owners have less control over freelancers than they do over employees, as freelancers work independently and are not bound by a specific work schedule.
• Limited Availability: Freelancers may only be available to work part-time, which could limit the amount of work they can do for a company.
• Quality Concerns: Not all freelancers are created equal, and there is a risk of hiring someone who may not produce the desired quality of work.
• Potential for Miscommunication: Without a consistent work schedule or in-person meetings, there is a greater potential for miscommunication between freelancers and their clients.

What is an Independent Contractor?

An independent contractor is a self-employed individual or business entity providing services to clients under a contract. Unlike employees, independent contractors are not subject to the same level of control or direction from the client, and they generally have more autonomy over how they perform their work. Independent contractors are responsible for their own taxes, insurance, and business expenses and are not eligible for employee benefits such as health insurance or retirement plans.

Characteristics of an Independent Contractor

• Control over Work: Independent contractors have more control over how they perform their work and are not subject to the same level of supervision as employees.
• Self-employment: Independent contractors are responsible for managing their own business operations, including invoicing, taxes, and marketing.
• Flexibility: Independent contractors offer flexibility, as they can be hired for short-term or long-term projects and can adjust their work hours to meet tight deadlines.
• Specialised Skills: Independent contractors often have a specific area of expertise and can offer a high level of skill and knowledge in their field.

Benefits of Hiring an Independent Contractor

• Cost-effective: Hiring an independent contractor can be less expensive than hiring a full-time employee, as they do not require benefits or office space.
• Specialised Skills: Independent contractors often have specific expertise and can provide high-quality work.
• Flexibility: Independent contractors offer flexibility, as they can be hired for short-term or long-term projects and can adjust their work hours to meet tight deadlines.
• Lower Liability: Independent contractors are responsible for their own insurance and business expenses, which can lower the client's liability.

Drawbacks of Hiring an Independent Contractor

• Less Control: Business owners have less control over independent contractors than they do over employees, as independent contractors work independently and are not bound by a specific work schedule.
• Possible Misclassification: If an independent contractor is misclassified, the business owner may be liable for back taxes, penalties, and interest.
• Lack of Loyalty: Independent contractors are not employees and may have a different level of loyalty or commitment to the client than a full-time employee.
• Quality Concerns: Not all independent contractors are created equal, and there is a risk of hiring someone who may not produce the desired quality of work.

Differences Between Freelancers and Independent Contractors

While both freelancers and independent contractors are self-employed individuals who provide services to clients on a project basis, there are some key differences between the two. They can be summarised as follows: 

Legal Distinction

The legal distinction between freelancers and independent contractors can vary depending on the jurisdiction and the specific laws that apply. Generally speaking, freelancers and independent contractors are considered self-employed individuals who are not considered employees of their companies.

The main legal distinction between freelancers and independent contractors is the nature of their work relationship with the company. Freelancers typically work on a project-by-project basis and are not committed to any long-term contract with a particular client. In contrast, independent contractors often have ongoing relationships with clients and may be contracted for a specific period.

Another important legal distinction is the company's degree of control over the work of the freelancer or independent contractor. Freelancers typically have more control over the way they perform their work, while independent contractors may be subject to more direction and supervision from the client.

Tax Implications for Both Parties

Both freelancers and independent contractors are considered self-employed individuals and are responsible for paying their own taxes. However, the specific tax implications can differ based on a few key factors.

Freelancers are typically paid on a project-by-project basis and may work with multiple clients throughout the year. They are responsible for reporting all income on their tax returns and paying self-employment taxes, which include Social Security and Medicare taxes. Additionally, freelancers may be eligible to deduct certain business expenses, such as equipment, software, and office supplies, on their tax returns.

On the other hand, independent contractors may work on longer-term projects or have ongoing relationships with clients. They are also responsible for reporting all income and paying self-employment taxes, but they may have additional tax obligations depending on the nature of their work. For example, independent contractors who work with certain types of clients, such as government agencies, may be required to obtain a tax identification number and file specific tax forms.

In addition to federal taxes, freelancers and independent contractors may be subject to state and local taxes, depending on where they live and work. Some states have specific tax laws for self-employed individuals, such as a state-level self-employment tax.

Type of Work Each Party Performs

With the emergence of new technologies, the distinction between freelancers and independent contractors has become even more nuanced, often depending on the nature of the work they undertake. Although there are some commonalities between the two designations, their services and client interactions differ in significant ways.

Freelancers typically provide creative or specialised services, such as writing, graphic design, or photography. They may work on short-term projects and are often paid by the project or by the hour. Freelancers often have more flexibility in terms of the projects they take on and the clients they work with.

Meanwhile, independent contractors may provide a broader range of services, including administrative, technical, or managerial services. They may work on longer-term projects or may have ongoing relationships with clients. Independent contractors may also be subject to more direction and supervision from their clients and may have less control over the way they perform their work.

Another difference between freelancers and independent contractors based on the type of work is the level of expertise required for each type of service. Freelancers typically have specialised skills or knowledge in a particular area, while independent contractors may have a broader range of skills and knowledge across multiple areas.

Which One Should You Choose?

Deciding whether to hire a freelancer or an independent contractor can depend on various factors. These may include the nature of the work, the length of the project, and the level of control the business requires over the worker. 

Here are some things to consider when deciding which one to choose:

• Type of Work: If you need specialised or creative services, such as writing or graphic design, a freelancer may be the best choice. If you need more technical or administrative support, such as web development or project management, an independent contractor may be a better fit.
• Project Length: If you have a short-term project, such as a one-time writing assignment or a specific graphic design project, a freelancer may be the most cost-effective choice. If you have a longer-term project or ongoing work, such as managing a project or overseeing a team, an independent contractor may be a better option.
• Level of Control: If you need more control over the worker's schedule, work process, and final deliverables, an independent contractor may be the better choice. If you are comfortable giving the worker more autonomy and flexibility, a freelancer may be a good option.
• Budget: Freelancers may be more cost-effective for shorter-term projects, as they may charge less per project or per hour. Independent contractors may be more expensive, but they may provide more value in terms of their expertise and experience.
• Legal Considerations: It's important to carefully review the legal requirements for hiring a freelancer or an independent contractor, as misclassification can result in legal and financial consequences. Businesses should consult with legal or HR experts to ensure they properly classify their workers and follow all relevant regulations.

Bottomline

Understanding the difference between freelancers and independent contractors is crucial for businesses that rely on these types of workers. By carefully considering the type of work, project length, level of control required, budget, and legal considerations, businesses can make an informed decision about whether to hire a freelancer or an independent contractor.

Regardless of the choice made, it's important to establish clear expectations, communication, and contractual agreements with the worker to ensure a successful working relationship.

As you make decisions for your business, staying up-to-date on the latest legal and regulatory requirements for hiring freelancers and independent contractors is essential. Seeking advice from legal or HR experts can ensure that you're following all applicable laws and regulations.

If you're a freelancer or independent contractor looking to build your business, make sure to understand the differences between the two and market yourself accordingly. Highlighting your specialised skills, expertise, and experience can help attract the right clients and build a successful business.

Overall, whether you're a business owner or a freelancer/independent contractor, understanding the nuances of these two classifications is crucial for building successful and mutually beneficial working relationships.